Unanswered Questions Don’t Need to be Your Barrier Against Belief in God

J. Warner Wallace's "Rapid Response" series takes on some of the biggest questions — and answers them.

By The Stream Published on November 27, 2016

Have you heard these before? Have you asked questions like these yourself?

Too many unanswered questions? That’s not unusual.

But J. Warner Wallace, retired cold-case detective and a frequent Stream contributor, has loads of great answers for questions like these, in his ongoing “Rapid Response” series at coldcasechristianity.com. You’ve probably already discovered each of these questions is linked to his quick answer there.

Part of the beauty of his answers is that they’re brief. “Rapid Response” is the theme indeed. Here’s his answer to the question about the gospel manuscripts not being identical, for one example:

I understand this objection; there are many places in the Gospels where scribes over the centuries made small changes, either intentionally or unintentionally, resulting in a different word or passage. These resulting variations can seem problematic, for sure. Some skeptics claim we can’t trust any of the New Testament because of the presence of these differences.

But let me offer some insight from how crime scenes are worked. I’ve never encountered to a crime scene that wasn’t messy. I wish every crime scene was an orderly collection of helpful evidence, but that’s seldom the case. Instead, crime scenes are filled with relevant evidence and unrelated artifacts. Some of these artifacts are simply items that were in the scene before the crime even started, and some are unrelated items deposited after the fact. Paramedics, for example, often rush to the scene to save the victim and make quite a mess. As a result, I often have blood smears, bandage packaging, medical supplies and more in my crime scene, all of which was caused by paramedics after the fact. None of these have evidential value in determining what happened or in identifying the suspect; they’re unrelated artifacts.

Now imagine I’m the detective working a case in which someone you cared about was murdered. How would you feel if I walked in and I said, “You know, I’d like to help you, but there’s a bunch of artifacts in this scene. I’m sorry. I can’t do anything for you.” I think you’d say, “Well, wait a minute, here. You’re being irresponsible and shirking your duty. You’re a detective! You’re supposed to separate the artifacts from the evidence so you can make your case.” I think you’d be correct in making those statements.

Detectives do have a duty and we fulfill it all the time, even in difficult crime scenes. We employ a technique, a process, to separate the artifacts from the evidence. By using this process, we’re able to determine what has evidential value and what doesn’t. We’re able to return the crime scene to the condition it was in prior to the entry of late artifacts, and we’re able to separate unrelated elements from important evidence.

It turns out the textual critics do the same thing with the Gospels. They have a process in place that helps them identify variations and late entries. Better yet, they are able to compare the manuscripts to determine the most reasonable original ‘reading’ for each verse. Even the skeptic who says, “I see a variation,” is employing this process, but incompletely. The same process that successfully identifies a variant can also be used to remove the artifact and reliably restore the document to its original condition, even if the ‘crime scene’ is messy.

Imagine if someone could take a picture of my crime scene every five minutes from the time of the crime to the time of my arrival at the scene. Once I got there, I could compare all these images to see what changed in my scene over time. By comparing these multiple images, I would know what entered late and I could restore the scene reliably to its original condition. The more images I have, the easier this process would be. We do something very similar when returning the New Testament to its original condition. We compare the thousands of manuscripts we have to identify what entered late and restore the manuscript reliably to its original condition.”

It’s a quick, informed, reasonable response — the kind of answer that helps a lot.

There’s lots more like this at J. Warner’s website, and indeed all over the internet. You and your friends don’t need to let unanswered questions keep you from Christianity.

 

Material adapted from ColdCaseChristianity.com. Used by permission.

Like the article? Share it with your friends! And use our social media pages to join or start the conversation! Find us on Facebook, X, Instagram, MeWe and Gab.

Inspiration
The Good Life
Katherine Wolf
More from The Stream
Connect with Us